@jojacob_uk @iLearningUK Thanks Jo. #ocTEL— Victoria Baxter (@vbaxter) June 25, 2014

@jojacob_uk @iLearningUK Thanks #ocTEL— Victoria Baxter (@vbaxter) June 25, 2014

My post-interview thoughts
Q1.  Thinking about Minecraft, what was the impetus and rationale behind using MC to teach with?
Minecraft is a sandbox experience which makes it ideal for creativity, exploration, ideas and concepts. As it doesn’t restrict you from the normal ‘rules’ of a game people in Minecraft can build and do pretty much what they want. In an interesting episode of Minecraft Minechat (episode 25) Andre Chercka discusses how he has set up a server for working with autistic children and in it he shows us houses with roofs built of watermelons (8:34). The idea that you can build a roof on a house made of watermelons is just incredible. You couldn’t do that with Lego. There isn’t a watermelon brick in Lego. But in Minecraft, you could build that roof with any of the 153+ blocks available to you. You are only limited by your imagination. 
So the sandbox approach that Minecraft allows is a creative, open-ended platform for learning that means crafters can experiment, explore, try things out in a safe, controlled way. It also allows them to cooperate, collaborate, communicate as well as teaching them secondary IT skills as they get more involved.
At some point, all crafters want to record their world and their activity in that world. So very quickly, they find out about screen casting, publishing to and setting up a YouTube channel, streaming their videos via twitch. These are all skills that will be useful in many online, digital environments so are transferable skills. In 2011, 53% of persons employed in the EU used a computer at work. Panorama, E.U.S., (2012). With this level of computer use only increasing in the workplace, the ability to be comfortable finding digital solutions to problems becomes more important.
Q2. What has teaching with MC achieved so far in terms of student learning?

Minecraft has been used to teach everything from Maths to History to Quantum Physics and computer programming. Minecraft has a healthy modding community (modding is the process of developing extra programmes or ‘modules’ that change the original game). There are several mods that allow you to further engage learners with a specific topic and many different communities using them. The mods often encourage collaboration and exploration through their games. In this way, learners are actively encouraged to find common themes and solutions to solve problems (Problem Based Learning – PBL). This approach can also integrate well with flipped learning as the two different pedagogies compliment each other.
The Minecraft community is largely self sufficient, providing updates to wikis, links to tutorials on youTube and walkthroughs on particular problems on Twitch. All of these resources allow the learner to progress their own learning in a self-structured way. Criticisms of this approach are that without the facilitators to guide the learning process, learners do not always lear what then need to. Without a facilitator in place, Minecraft sessions can quickly disrupt in to griefing sessions, or just personal build projects with little or no direction or apparent purpose.

I usually show this video to explain how minecraft could be used in education http://youtu.be/RI0BN5AWOe8
Read more at http://www.ilearninguk.com/archives/174#DPT6erxok3LU2BMc.99

Q3. What impact have you seen on staff where you have delivered MC in schools?

Adam talks about moving away from more traditional forms of teaching in to a more playful approach. I like the idea of this and support making learning enjoyable at any age. Getting engagement with the learning is all about making a connection with the learner. We do this with great presentations, with humour, with our personalities, but we can also use technology that they understand and enjoy to deliver our messages. The properties of gamification as defined by González, C., & Area, M. (2010)  fits with Minecraft as a learning tool and therefore we can consider it suitable for gamification of learning.
The change in one’s own pedagogic practice can indeed be a daunting prospect as Adam noted, as there is scope for failure and issues with employing new technology that has yet to be proven in a classroom environment. However, once initial fears are overcome through the support and facilitation of a good TEL advisor and with the continuing support of other teachers using minecraft such as the Google group for teachers there is lots of opportunity and scope to try out new ideas and to get creative with the teaching.
Minecraft use in Higher Education learning is largely unexplored at this point in time with few studies or research being conducted in this area. My own research is in the use and design of learning spaces in the virtual world and whether one can or indeed should look to replicate real world learning spaces in the virtual ones. I certainly will be looking to explore the use of Minecraft in Higher Education as a learning tool.
Q4. How do you know it has had this impact? What evaluation strategies and methods have been used?

Minecraft seems to have been a catalyst for many teachers who are finding new and exciting ways to use it in an educational way. Adam reports that he gets feedback from teachers who have initiated new projects based around Minecraft and the excitement that has generated.
He also reports that the University of Lancaster are working on a Minecraft Democracy project and that this will be measured through questionnaires and post project interviews. It is hoped that this will demonstrate links between the skills and how Minecraft can be used to engage and develop new concepts in teaching.
It is always hard to establish a cause and effect relationship between a learning intervention and a resulting positive, measurable impact. There is no doubt that utilising Minecraft can and does stimulate discussion, creativity and experimentation, but at present there is little science behind the results. We have studies of gamification of learning and measurable impacts against control groups, but perhaps the very sandbox nature of Minecraft makes it harder to control and therefore harder to measure? Does Minecraft need to be measured or is there a role for it to play in allowing students to be in control of their own learning? What ever the answer may be to this question, Minecraft surely has made an impact educationally.
González, C., & Area, M. (2010). Breaking the Rules: Gamification of Learning and Educational Materials. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Interaction Design in Educational Environments (pp. 47–53). SciTePress – Science and and Technology Publications. doi:10.5220/0004600900470053
Panorama, E. U. S. (2012). Digital Competence Analytical Highlight. Retrieved from http://euskillspanorama.cedefop.europa.eu/docs/AnalyticalHighlights/DigitalCompetence_en.pdf
 

“@iLearningUK: @jojacob_uk errrrm no [yes]” An #octel leader board would be interesting… just for fun of course!— Jo Jacob (@jojacob_uk) June 24, 2014

“@iLearningUK: #ocTEL is there going to be a league table of Achievement points? My Total Points: 8,305” Getting competitive?— Jo Jacob (@jojacob_uk) June 24, 2014

@vbaxter @iLearningUK The bottom of the #octel right hand column shows your total score… not that I’ve looked or anything— Jo Jacob (@jojacob_uk) June 24, 2014

@iLearningUK How do we find out how many points we have gathered? #ocTEL— Victoria Baxter (@vbaxter) June 24, 2014

@guy75 @iLearningUK next time 😉 there might be an #ocTEL session at the ALT conference in Sept https://t.co/1aCFbq1Gvm— Martin Hawksey (@mhawksey) June 24, 2014

@syrupskriss you might be interested in this Chris. My article for #ocTEL on the use of Minecraft in Education. http://t.co/3g0J5zStU3— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 24, 2014

#ocTEL is there going to be a league table of Achievement points? My Total Points: 8,305— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 24, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Week 6: Activity 6.3: – Exploring enhancement and evaluation in practice http://t.co/0C4dlaY5tU— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 24, 2014

@iLearningUK @mhawksey would love to make trip up, but stuck down here with fun student project pitches. Should make them #ocTEL related!— Guy Saward (@guy75) June 23, 2014

Finally met the brains behind #ocTEL at #GEUG14. Good to meet you too @mhawksey :)— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 23, 2014

I was not expecting to meet an #octel participant at #geug14. Great to finally meet @iLearningUK in person :)— Martin Hawksey (@mhawksey) June 23, 2014

@jojacob_uk I think so… I still have a few extras to post up yet! I am going to post more explorer thoughts where you can. #ocTEL— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 23, 2014

iLearning UK | #ocTEL week 6: Tel One Badge: How to enhance the effectiveness and e… | @scoopit via @iLearningUK http://t.co/sDXhwTWhQ3— Teresa MacKinnon (@WarwickLanguage) June 22, 2014

Twitter interview with Adam Clarke aka – Professor_Adam – aka @thecommonpeople

@iLearningUK – Joel Mills

@thecommonpeople – Adam Clarke

40m
Hi Adam, Would you be up for a quick twitter interview with me? I am on an #ocTEL course looking at innovative Learning & I thought of you!

39m
Yes

36m
Brill! Ok. There are 4 Qs. Thinking about Minecraft, what was the impetus and rationale behind using MC to teach with?

34m
MC is an easy to use multiplayer virtual space where the player can be creative and share ideas in 3D

34m
And so much more…

32m
Ok, Q2. What has teaching with MC achieved so far in terms of student learning?

30m
Student can learn everything from maths – physics – art – history – the difference is the process is game based and often collaborative

29m
I usually show this video to explain how minecraft could be used in education http://youtu.be/RI0BN5AWOe8

27m
Thanks for that. I’ll take a look. I use MinecraftEDU to teach with but I know you have done lofts of work in a broader context. 1 of 2

26m
Yes mapping – biology and story telling – minecraft is a great narrative container for engagement – taking the learner on a journey

26m

Q3. What impact have you seen on staff where you have delivered MC in schools? 2 of 2

25m
And your museum project?…

24m
Its given opportunities for cross curricula projects that really are across the curiculam [sic]

23m
so teachers start with traditional ideas but can move beyond into more playful and student led learning – project based

22m
My museum work uses minecraft as a peer reviewed game where knowledge and learning is discussed between the students

22m
The teachers become assistant and instigators to learning

21m
Going back to Q3 for a second, Did you see a direct impact on staff in schools after you had delivered MC sessions? More enthused/engaged?

20m
A mix – change can be hard – some nervous – but yes lots of new ideas – lots of improved enthusiasm and agency to be creative

19m
Final #ocTEL question. Q4. How do you know it has had this impact? What evaluation strategies and methods have been used?

17m
For me there has been initial feed back and I get reports from teachers letting me know about current projects –

16m
We are currently working with Lancaster Uni on a minecraft democracy project and will be using academic strategies

15m
Questionnaire interviews and post project interviews

15m
This will show – we hope the transfer was of skills and ideas / concepts and engagement

14m
So it’s about the why question – eg if you use mc for teaching and learning then it’s good to know why – then it’s easy to evaluate

14m
That sounds very interesting. I am particularly keen on using MC in an HE context. I am a TEL advisor at the University of Hull. 1 of 2

12m
I am looking at creating a 6 week MOOC in MC for Education and about to undertake my MSc in Learning Spaces looking at real and virtual.

11
m
Sound brilliant – would love to help on a Mooc

8m
Do I have your permission to include a transcript of this conversation on my blog? You can say no.

52s
Sure take care

now
Finally then. Just to say thank you very much Adam Clarke @thecommonpeople for your time and I look forward to seeing more of your work.

New post: #ocTEL week 6: Tel One Badge: How to enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of particular TEL approaches http://t.co/AcwSsHq7sG— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 20, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Week 6: Activity 6.3: – The interview with @thecommonpeople http://t.co/GCnMAR4WC1— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 20, 2014

#lGmlearning is this the future of our educators? Not a single tweet using the # at a mobile learning conference full of educators? #ocTEL— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 18, 2014

#lGmlearning why is no one tweeting at this conference on Mobile learning? Might have to reflect on this in #ocTel— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 18, 2014

@iLearningUK Thanks for an excellent SWOT analysis of self-hosted vs externally hosted and open source vs paid for #ocTEL— Julie Voce (@julievoce) June 17, 2014

New post: #ocTEL week 5: Explorer activity 5.4 http://t.co/KgYdqqigYV— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 16, 2014

New post: #ocTEL week 5: TEL one Badge http://t.co/ZDFnCuW46N— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 16, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Week 4: Tel Explorer Badge 4.5: Reflecting on Peer feedback http://t.co/1Pyfv9anHn— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 12, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Week 4: TEL one Badge http://t.co/q02hTTUwUw— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 12, 2014

#octel Right. Check-in badge for week 4: TICK Here we go for the second half— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 02, 2014

#octel Great news @mhawksey. I Cant wait to transfer all my badges over. Just waiting for my week 3 badges…— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) June 02, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Explorer activity 3.5: Evaluating a resource in your area http://t.co/ZFsxVEXhkI— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 29, 2014

@romieh @iLearningUK good point #ocTEL— Martin Hawksey (@mhawksey) May 28, 2014

@mhawksey @iLearningUK maybe replace ‘tutor’ with ‘facilitation’ next time as I think the response might be different. #octel— Rose Heaney (@romieh) May 28, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Explorer Activity 3.4: Learning styles http://t.co/hN0UMJTzKe— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 28, 2014

@iLearningUK another interesting response from the survey was the tutor support has no influence on engagement #octel #selfregulation ;)— Martin Hawksey (@mhawksey) May 27, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Week 3: TEL One Badge http://t.co/FCUnI3skQe— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 27, 2014

@mhawksey Using reading week to catch up on week 3… But the motivation is there to participate! #octel— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 27, 2014

New post: #ocTEL 2.5 Active Play http://t.co/AjYKZE3Yyl— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 27, 2014

New post: #ocTEL Activity 2.4(a) Design an Authentic Learning Activity http://t.co/d87hH8tQOS— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 27, 2014

#LFLLL1314 #ocTEL Great analogy of “Slime communities” relating to collaborative learning from Dr Nick Almond. I am going to use this— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 22, 2014

-long post warning!-

In fact, the technology and protocols for continuous assessment of learners already exists. e-portfolios are an excellent way of organizing continuous assessment . The practice of using them is also well researched and the technologies are improving all the…[Read more]

New post: #ocTEL Week 2: If you only do one thing… http://t.co/WOMJmIN9Ma— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 21, 2014

@iLearningUK I am using #ocTEL for: #Reflection #Networking #Skills #Other – new ideas, CMALT— Sally Chappell (@Sal_Chappell) May 13, 2014

Lectures Aren’t Just Boring, They’re Ineffective, Too, Study Finds http://t.co/JiEmPSrvXE via @feedly #ocTEL— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 13, 2014

@mhawksey @chcoll @iLearningUK count my hand up as well! #ocTEL— Jennifer Englund (@jmenglund03) May 12, 2014

@iLearningUK Twit-Poll I am using #ocTEL for #reflection #skills #other – for CMALT, new resources, professional dev. Yes, working so far.— Clare Thomson (@ClareThomsonQUB) May 12, 2014

@iLearningUK Twit-poll I am using #ocTEL for #reflection, #new_tech, #skills, #professionaldevelopment, #examples And so far it’s working!— chcoll (@chcoll) May 12, 2014

@iLearningUK #ocTEL Twit-Poll I am using #ocTEL for? #Reflection #Networking #New_tech #EnhancementOfLearning #ProfessionalDevelopment— Chris Jobling (@cpjobling) May 12, 2014

@iLearningUK: #ocTEL Twit-Poll I am using #ocTEL for #Reflection #New_tech #Networking— Dr Jennie Swann (@jswann) May 12, 2014

using #octel for #networking #reflection #IdeasForMyOwnTeaching @iLearningUK— Maha Bali (@Bali_Maha) May 12, 2014

#ocTEL Twit-Poll I am using #ocTEL for? {del as required} #Reflection #New_tech #Networking #Badges #Skills #Other (please expand)— Joel Mills (@iLearningUK) May 12, 2014